| 2024-25 | Josh Kight | | 2021-23 | Jacob Stidham | | 2020 | Jeff Wallitsch | | 2017-19 | Michael Mueller | | 2016-17 | Kim Fritz | | 2014-15 | Martin Korfhage | | 2012-13 | Tom Weeks | | 2009-11 | Todd Ryan | | 2007-08 | Mike Driesback | | 2005-06 | Larry Sanders | | 2003-04 | Jim Wallitsch | | 2001-02 | Hugo Davis | | 1999-00 | Charlie Wilson | | 1997-98 | Mike Land | | 1994-96 | Casey Schott | | | |
| |
| 1992-93 | Mike Ray | | 1990-91 | Rick Frederick | | 1988-89 | Bob Korfhage | | 1986-87 | John Frost | | 1984-85 | Melvin Moffett | | 1982-83 | Lynn Reeves | | 1980-81 | Bob Maddox | | 1978-79 | Jim Merchant | | 1976-77 | John Korfhage | | 1974-75 | Louis Hillenmeyer, III | | 1972-73 | Jim Singer | | 1970-71 | Robert Korfhage | | 1968-69 | Richard Ammon | | 1966-67 | John Schevetto | | 1964-65 | Donald J. Hillenmeyer | | 1962-63 | Charles M. Law | | | |
| |
| 1960-61 | Robert H. Hillenmeyer | | 1958-59 | Herman R. Wallitsch | | 1956-57 | Richard Taliaferro | | 1954-55 | Mitchell Leichhardt | | 1951-53 | W.W. Hillenmeyer, Jr. | | 1949-50 | Dan B. Gardiner | | 1947-48 | Carl Ray | | 1945-46 | A. Gart Humphreys | | 1942-44 | Louis Hillenmeyer, Jr. | | 1940-41 | Joseph W. Fike | | 1938-39 | Alvin Kidwell | | 1936-37 | Martin J. Yopp | | 1934-35 | Theodore Zollinger | | 1932-33 | Rudy L. Haag | | 1930-31 | A. L. Hager | | 1928-29 | Louis E. Hillenmeyer | | 1926-27 | W.W. Hillenmeyer |
|
